Close
Get Listed
Laurels

Best Car Insurance Agencies in Indianapolis
2021

We scored 462 Car Insurance Agencies in Indianapolis, IN and Picked the Top 10

Here are the Picks:

Accurate Auto Insurance

Associated Insurance Services

Classic Auto Insurance

Exceed Insurance

Jackson-McCormick Insurance

Jensen Ford Insurance Agency

Penwell Insurance

Select Insurance Group

Simple Choice Agency

Steffey Hatoway Insurance

Why These Car Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Indianapolis Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 462 281 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Accurate Auto Insurance

Founded in 1992, Accurate Auto Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in the Indianapolis, Indiana, metro area. Coverage specialists work with several top-rated carriers to find clients the right policy, including drivers with accidents, tickets, and suspended licenses. Options include bodily injury and property damage liability, and the choice of adding collision and comprehensive coverage. Plans are also available for motorcycles and ride share vehicles. Discounts are available for proof of prior insurance, multi-vehicle policies, and perfect driving records.

Click to Call

1075 Broad Ripple Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46220

Website

(219) 836-9400 Website

Associated Insurance Services

Associated Insurance Services offers around-the-clock service to its customers in Indianapolis, Indiana. It works with providers such as Liberty Mutual and Progressive to protect drivers from the financial hardship associated with vehicle accidents and theft. Policies include bodily injury liability and personal liability coverage. Other coverage options include collision, comprehensive, and medical payments insurance. Associated Insurance Services is a Trusted Choice independent insurance agent and a member of the Greater Lawrence Chamber of Commerce.

Click to Call

11502 Moore St
Fishers, IN 46038

Website

(317) 520-9300 Website

Classic Auto Insurance

Classic Auto Insurance, based out of Indianapolis, Indiana, specializes in insurance products for antique, classic, exotic, and luxury automobiles. The company has over 15 years of experience and can offer customizable plans to suit its clients' needs. Classic Auto Insurance also offers flexible and rollover mileage plans. Potential customers can fill out information to get an instant quote before speaking to an agent, and existing clients speak highly of the company's promptness and attention to detail.

Click to Call

9402 Uptown Dr Ste 800
Indianapolis, IN 46256

Website

(888) 901-1338 Website

Reputation: A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

2 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Exceed Insurance

Based in Indianapolis, Indiana, with offices in Sacramento, California, Exceed Insurance is an independent agency serving the cities' metro areas. Founded in 2000, the auto insurance specialist also provides home, life, trucking, and commercial insurance services. Auto insurance coverage from the agency's list of carriers includes paying for vehicle damage or its theft, the driver's legal responsibilities if another party or property is damaged in the accident, and medical coverage to treat injuries and meet rehabilitation costs.

Click to Call

4150 Lafayette Rd Ste I
Indianapolis, IN 46254

Website

(317) 295-1279 Website

Reputation: A

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

1 (Good)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

2 (Good)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Jackson-McCormick Insurance

Based in Lebanon, Indiana, Jackson-McCormick Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving clients throughout the Indianapolis metro area. Partnerships with national insurers such as Nationwide and Safeco enable the agency to provide auto insurance to car, truck, and motorcycle owners of all ages. Budget-conscious drivers can choose a liability-only policy, while those seeking the most robust protection opt for full-coverage policies that include property damage, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist coverage. Jackson-McCormick Insurance also offers commercial policies.

Click to Call

210 E Main St
Lebanon, IN 46052

Website

(765) 482-3730 Website

Jensen Ford Insurance Agency

Jensen Ford Agency in Indianapolis, Indiana, utilizes a network of prominent auto insurance carriers to help locals procure insurance coverage and rate options. The company has been in business since 1946 and applies 70 years' worth of experience to the advice it gives motorists seeking necessary auto insurance. Coverage options include collision and comprehensive, liability, road trouble service, and lease/loan gap coverage. It also writes motorcycle, boat, homeowners, and renters insurance.

Click to Call

8000 S Meridian St Ste A
Indianapolis, IN 46217

Website

(317) 888-6007 Website

Penwell Insurance

Penwell Insurance provides auto insurance consultation and agent services to clients living in the Indianapolis, Indiana, metro area. It educates clients on the legal requirements of insurance policies and corresponds with various providers to help them explore rates and optional coverage areas. This agency works with both personal and business clients, offering auto insurance services for business vehicles and commercial fleets as well. Besides automobiles, Penwell Insurance also provides home, business, and general liability insurance services.

Click to Call

600 E Carmel Dr
Carmel, IN 46032

Website

(317) 559-3022 Website

Select Insurance Group

Select Insurance Group is an independent auto insurance agency serving high-risk drivers across the country from its individually-owned offices, including in Indianapolis, Indiana. The company partners with a wide variety of insurers to help clients with histories of accidents, violations, and poor credit obtain coverage that meets their budget. Select Insurance Group specializes in navigating SR22 and FR44 laws and has experience helping clients get hardship and restricted licenses. The company also provides non-owner auto policies.

Click to Call

8888 Keystone Xing Ste 1300
Indianapolis, IN 46240

Website

(855) 438-7353 Website

Simple Choice Agency

Simple Choice Agency is an Avon, Indiana, based independent insurance agency offering auto insurance to clients in the Indianapolis, Indiana, region. The company's agents shop to find personalized insurance policies with options that include bodily injury and liability, property damage, and collision coverage for the most common auto insurance needs. Additional options include medical payment coverage and comprehensive coverage that financially protects clients and their vehicles against damage not arising from automobile collisions.

Click to Call

6319 E US Highway 36 Ste 208
Avon, IN 46123

Website

(317) 837-4960 Website

Steffey Hatoway Insurance

Steffey Hatoway Insurance is an Indianapolis, Indiana, insurance agency that sells auto insurance and other insurance products throughout the Indianapolis, metro area. Founded in 1982, the agency provides personal auto insurance with the usual liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage but with options for accident forgiveness, rental car coverage, new car replacement, roadside assistance, and pet injury coverage. Commercial auto premiums are determined by factors such as the age of the driver, number of vehicles, driving record, and age of the vehicle.

Click to Call

8365 Keystone Xing Ste 202
Indianapolis, IN 46240

Website

(317) 334-3743 Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area