Close
Get Listed
Laurels

Best Insurance Agencies in Fort Wayne
2020

We scored 70 Insurance Agencies in Fort Wayne, IN and Picked the Top 12

hero image

Here are the Picks:

AE Wegmann Agency

Amstutz Insurance

Andrea S Baumer

Brady Benefits & Associates

Hartman Insurance Services

Health Insurance Shop, Inc.

Mitson Insurance Agency

Murphy Insurance

Myers & Hayden Insurance

Runestad Financial Services

S & J Insurance

Traxler Insurance

Why These Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Fort Wayne Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 70 46 12

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 2. Qualifications

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 4. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

AE Wegmann Agency

AE Wegmann Agency helps Fort Wayne customers navigate the complexities of the life insurance marketplace. Founded in 1962, this family-owned independent insurance agency provides comprehensive insurance solutions from an array of nationally known carriers. Its goal is to help clients get the best possible coverage for their budgets while providing personalized service and helping handle any claims or policy service. In addition to life insurance coverage, the agency also helps customers find auto, home, and business insurance.

Click to Call

22335 Main St
Woodburn, IN 46797

Website

(260) 632-4313 Website

Amstutz Insurance

Amstutz Insurance is a life insurance agency in Fort Wayne. Founded in 1939, this family-run business is an independent insurance company with more than 80 years of industry expertise. It offers conventional life insurance for families and individuals, and it works with top companies across the nation to get customers the health insurance plans they need. Its agents help clients access their needs to find the right provider, coverage type, copayment, and deductible, from comprehensive to basic policies.

Click to Call

4105 W Jefferson Blvd
Fort Wayne, IN 46804

Website

(260) 432-8736 Website

Andrea S Baumer

Andrea S. Baumer helps Fort Wayne customers determine their life and health insurance needs and matches them with insurance carriers in its portfolio of partners. Some of its life insurance products include individual life insurance, fixed annuities, and final expense insurance, and it sells life insurance for groups. Health insurance offerings include individual long-term care insurance, individual disability insurance, and Medicare supplement/Advantage plans. In addition, Andrea S. Baumer offers auto, home, personal, and business insurance products.

Click to Call

227 S 2nd St
Decatur, IN 46733

Website

(260) 676-2680 Website

Brady Benefits & Associates

Brady Benefits & Associates in Fort Wayne offers life and health insurance coverage for the local market. It primarily serves employers and employees with group benefits, including group health, life, dental, vision, and long-term disability. Other areas of focus include accident insurance coverage, critical illness, sickness, and short-term disability. Some of the top national carriers Brady Benefits & Associates works with include UnitedHealthcare, Consumers Life Insurance Company, ASR Health Benefits, and Cigna.

Click to Call

1731 Ruskin Ct
Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Website

(260) 220-8800 Website

Hartman Insurance Services

In business for more than 36 years, Hartman Insurance Services serves the insurance needs of Fort Wayne, with life and health insurance among its specialties. This independent agency's goal is to empower its clients to make informed decisions when buying health and life insurance. The agency sells conventional life insurance, and it offers a host of medical plans, including short-term medical, Part D coverage, major medical/ACA, Medicare Advantage plans, and dental/vision/hearing plans.

Click to Call

215 Airport North Office Park
Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Website

(260) 483-2305 Website

Health Insurance Shop, Inc.

Health Insurance Shop Inc. is a life insurance company in Fort Wayne that sells several types of insurance. Founded in 1981, this independent insurance agency offers a host of insurance products, including life insurance for individuals and family in both whole life and temporary, or term, life formats. Its health insurance offerings include individual health plans, group health coverage, short-term major medical, Medicare plans and supplements, and individual dental and vision coverage plans.

Click to Call

3609 Lake Ave
Fort Wayne, IN 46805

Website

(260) 484-7010 Website

Mitson Insurance Agency

Mitson Insurance Agency is a life insurance agency in Fort Wayne that offers both term and permanent, whole life insurance policies. It offers quotes via its website or in person at its physical location. Some of the carriers for which this independent agency connects customers include The Hartford, Foremost Insurance Group, and Safeco Insurance. In addition to life insurance, Mitson Insurance Agency offers health insurance, disability insurance, and long-term care insurance policies.

Click to Call

6500 E State Blvd
Fort Wayne, IN 46815

Website

(260) 749-0100 Website

Murphy Insurance

Founded in 1934, Murphy Insurance helps Fort Wayne customers find the right policies for their health and life insurance needs. Owner Tom Murphy has more than 53 years of experience in the insurance industry. This hometown insurance agent offers a range of life and health policies, including individual life insurance. Its health lines include health insurance, Medicare Advantage policies, and Medicare supplement plans. Additional policies available include auto, home, RV, high-risk auto, mobile home, and motorcycle.

Click to Call

626 Broadway St
New Haven, IN 46774

Website

(260) 749-1812 Website

Myers & Hayden Insurance

Myers & Hayden Insurance is a life insurance company in Fort Wayne with more than 30 years serving the local area's insurance needs. This independent insurance agency sells an array of life insurance types, from individual life insurance policies to life insurance for children and key man life insurance for businesses. Its personal lines team helps with some types of health insurance, including Medicare supplement plans for seniors and other Medicare recipients.

Click to Call

3490 Stellhorn Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46815

Website Instagram

(260) 486-5255 Website

Reputation: A+

More Info

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.

Online Profiles:

2 (Better)

Average Review Score:

5 / 5 (Best)

Total Reviews:

19 (Better)

Score Consistency:

Consistent (Best)

Runestad Financial Services

Runestad Financial Services offers its insurance industry expertise to customers in Fort Wayne. Ric Runestad has more than a quarter-century in the insurance sector and is a member of the Million Dollar Round table. The agency offers a complete line of life and health products, including individual health and dental coverage, vision insurance, disability insurance, prescription drug coverage, and Medicare supplement and Advantage plans. Additionally, the agency offers retirement income and wealth management services.

Click to Call

9726 Saint Joseph St # SR1
Leo, IN 46765

Website

(260) 627-3333 Website

S & J Insurance

Founded in 1995, S&J Insurance is a health insurance company in Fort Wayne offering a range of products to help clients get the coverage they and their families need. This independent agency offers a comprehensive selection of policies for life insurance and health insurance clients. Its health insurance options range from individual health insurance to dental coverage, Medicare supplement coverage, and family insurance. Life insurance offerings include short term and whole life policies and final expense insurance.

Click to Call

3484 Stellhorn Rd Ste B
Fort Wayne, IN 46815

Website

(866) 269-7562 Website

Traxler Insurance

Traxler Insurance helps Fort Wayne customers find the right life and health insurance plans for their needs and their particular situations. This local independent agency helps customers compare quotes with top companies to get rates that are fair and competitive when shopping for life and health policies. Other policy types available include home, auto, boat, RV, business, and specialty coverage. The agency is a member of the Professional Insurance Agents of Indiana (PIA).

Click to Call

10729 Coldwater Rd Ste 100
Fort Wayne, IN 46845

Website

(260) 494-9035 Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area