Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Fort Wayne

Why These Homeowners Insurance Agencies?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored Fort Wayne Homeowners Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

Reviewed Curated Top Picks 152 95 10

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Archbold & Lewis Insurance Inc.

Archbold & Lewis Insurance Inc. is an insurance brokerage firm in Ossian, Indiana, serving clients throughout the greater Fort Wayne region and the surrounding communities. The business provides a suite of insurance solutions for homeowners and renters seeking to insure their property against losses from natural disasters, theft, vandalism, or other life events. Policies provide home, condo, renters, farm, and mobile home insurance coverage. Archbold & Lewis Insurance Inc. also sells auto and business insurance.

105 S Jefferson St
Ossian, IN 46777


Godschalk and Associates

Godschalk and Associates is an independent insurance agency that provides home insurance in Fort Wayne, Indiana and throughout northeast Indiana. The company offers home insurance options that protect residential households against fire, burglary, weather damage, and other unforeseen events. Since 1982, the company has offered home insurance and other insurance products to commercial and personal clients from a variety of carriers. Godschalk and Associates also sells auto, property, life, and business insurance.

405 Lower Huntington Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46819


Hoch Insurance

Located in Fort Wayne, Indiana, with additional offices in Leo and Indianapolis, Hoch Insurance is a large independent insurance agency that provides service to clients throughout northeast and central Indiana. It is affiliated with 16 insurance partners, including Progressive and Liberty Mutual. Hoch Insurance offers homeowners insurance with diverse coverage options. In addition to liability and property damage, it offers specialized coverage for items such as collectible vehicles, wine collections, and personal injury, including reputation damage.

209 E Washington Center Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46825


Hupe Insurance Services

Established in 1981 by Roger Hupe, Hupe Insurance Services is an independent agency serving Fort Wayne, Indiana, and the surrounding area. As an independent insurance company, the agents have access to a wide variety of providers that offer personal auto and homeowners insurance, business insurance, individual and group health, and life insurance options customized to fit each client's needs. Hupe agents assist customers in determining their primary and optional coverage requirements to provide competitive services and pricing.

7011 Stellhorn Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46815


Imel Insurance agency

Imel Insurance Agency is an independent company located in Fort Wayne, Indiana, that has provided residents and business owners with insurance options for more than 50 years. Personal insurance may include home, auto, or renter's coverage as well as personal identity theft and valuable items protection. Commercial coverage could involve property and autos as well as surety bonds and individual liability. Farm insurance protects residence and other farm buildings and contents. Pet care is another policy offered by Imel.

2700 Lower Huntington Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46809


Integrity Insurance

Integrity Insurance is a locally owned independent agency serving Fort Wayne, Indiana, and the surrounding area. The agents work with a select group of insurance providers to offer clients responsive customer service and competitive pricing, creating homeowner policies to meet individual client requirements. Coverage encompasses protection for the structure itself as well as any repairs needed as the result of a natural disaster. Integrity Insurance establishes appropriate replacement value in the event of theft and prioritizes homeowners liability protection.

10542 Coldwater Rd Ste A
Fort Wayne, IN 46845


Lederman Insurance

Lederman Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Fort Wayne, Indiana, serving residents with tailored insurance policies for more than 45 years. It provides home insurance policies to renters, homeowners, and condo owners throughout Fort Worth and surrounding areas. President Michael Lederman had more than 26 years of experience in the insurance industry, and the company provides comprehensive insurance packages. Home insurance options include cover for fire damage, hail, burglary, sewer and water backups, and equipment breakdowns.

217 E Washington Center Rd
Fort Wayne, IN 46825


Luttman Insurance Inc.

Luttman Insurance is a locally owned independent insurance agency based in Fort Wayne, Indiana. Founded in 1994, it partners with 10 national carriers to help homeowners find policies that meet their needs and budget. The agency offers umbrella coverage, which can protect homes from lawsuits and give additional protection for accidents involving recreational vehicles, such as ATVs, snowmobiles, and boats. Luttman Insurance also provides auto, mobile home, commercial, and contractor insurance policies.

707 Airport North Office Park
Fort Wayne, IN 46825


Ovation Insurance

Ovation Insurance is an independent agency offering home insurance policies to clients within the Fort Wayne, Indiana, metro area, as well as areas of Ohio. It assists clients with structuring policies that include an assortment of standard coverage areas including liability, comprehensive, collision, and property damage, and provides consultation as they shop for rates provided by associated underwriters. In addition to home insurance, this agency also handles auto, church, and wedding insurance policies.

6058 E State Blvd
Fort Wayne, IN 46815


Schultheis Insurance Agency

Established by Frank M. Schultheis, Sr. in 1944, the Schultheis Insurance Agency remained an independent family-owned company serving Evansville, Indiana, and the surrounding areas. It partners with more than 150 providers to offer clients the most cost-effective options for their personal and commercial insurance needs. From individual health coverage to group plans and mine subsidence policies, Schultheis creates a custom policy based on specific needs. In addition to health, the company provides auto, home, life, and business insurance.

1910 Saint Joe Center Rd Ste 11
Fort Wayne, IN 46825


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places:

Other top picks in your area