Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Fort Wayne

Laurels
Laurels

We did the research for you!

Learn more
  • checkboxLicensing
  • checkboxUser Reviews
  • checkboxMystery Shopping Calls

Homeowners Insurance Agencies FAQs

Learn more
Amstutz Insurance logo

Amstutz Insurance

4302 Flagstaff Cove, Fort Wayne, IN 46815
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types

Amstutz Insurance, Inc., offers its products and services to clients within Fort Wayne and the adjacent communities. Since 1939, the company has been providing homeowners and renters with insurance coverage for their furniture, electronics, and other personal belongings. Its staff is available for consultations with clients regarding the options behind each product and which one fits their budget and needs in terms of providing financial security. It also offers other personal insurance products for the healthcare, annuity, and retirement needs of seniors.

Visit Website
Associated Insurance Agencies Inc logo

Associated Insurance Agencies Inc

Fort Wayne, IN
Visit Website
  • Condos

Associated Insurance Agencies Inc. is a team of independent risk management specialists serving the Fort Wayne area. They furnish insurance plans for homeowners looking to protect their dwelling places and personal belongings such as electronics and jewelry. The team also write home insurance policies that cover vacation homes, secondary residences, and high-value residential properties. With access to coverage options from multiple providers such as Chubb, Auto-Owners, and American Modern, they are able to find plans that suit clients' needs.

Visit Website
Ball Group Inc logo

Ball Group Inc

1028 W Cook Rd Suite B, Fort Wayne, IN 46825
Visit Website
  • Homeowners

Established in 1979, Ball Group Inc. is an insurance agency serving Fort Wayne. It specializes in personal and commercial insurance coverages, which include homeowners, auto, and life insurance. The business also pairs business owners with commercial coverages, such as church, non-profit, and senior living insurance. The agents assist clients through the process, finding the policies that work best for them. Ball Group represents an extensive network of carriers, including Progressive, Foremost, Travelers, Grinnell Mutual, and Bristol West.

Visit Website
Berner and Company, Inc. logo

Berner and Company, Inc.

10538 Coldwater Road, Fort Wayne, IN 46845
Visit Website
  • Homeowners

Berner and Company Inc. Insurance is a family-owned and family-operated business that has been serving individuals and businesses throughout the area of Fort Wayne for more than 30 years. It offers a wide range of insurance products, such as homeowners', general liability, short-term health, farm property, Medicare Supplement, and life insurance. Its team of independent agents collaborates with several carefully sought-out carriers to provide clients with tailored insurance coverage. The founder and a CPIA, Tim Berner, has a master's degree in business administration.

Visit Website
Bixler Insurance, Inc. logo

Bixler Insurance, Inc.

10315 Dawson’s Creek Blvd, Suite H, Fort Wayne, IN 46825
Visit Website
  • Multiple Carriers

Bixler Insurance, Inc., is an independent agency that started as a small firm in 1946. It helps individuals in the Fort Wayne metro avoid getting caught unprepared by offering personal insurance products, such as home, life, health, and auto. Its homeowners' insurance plan covers the consumers' dwelling, stolen or damaged belongings, and liability. The company also provides commercial insurance policies. Its agent, Andrew Flueckiger, is a certified insurance counselor. He has worked in the sales and marketing industries before joining the company.

Visit Website
Cornerstone Insurance logo

Cornerstone Insurance

6001 N Clinton St, Fort Wayne, IN 46825-4903
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Landlords
  • Homeowners
  • Multiple Policy Types
  • Condos

Cornerstone Insurance is a local homeowners' insurance agency serving residents in Fort Wayne and the surrounding areas. In business for 24 years, Cornerstone Insurance's team of home insurance advisors provides information and assistance to potential insurance buyers in obtaining home quotes that match their financial situation and needs. Aside from homeowners' insurance, the team also offers other options, such as condo insurance, mobile home insurance, landlord insurance, renter's insurance, and vacation property insurance.

Visit Website
EPCO logo

EPCO

6010 E State Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46815
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Homeowners

For over 40 years, EPCO has been providing risk protection products in Fort Wayne. Its diverse offerings include auto, homeowners', and commercial insurance policies. Treating clients like family, the company's agents accommodate clients' concerns anytime to help assess their situation and find coverages tailored to their needs. The homeowners' and farmers' insurance cover antiques, collector's items, and jewelry. EPCO also caters to clients in need of flood and umbrella liability options and tax preparation assistance.

Visit Website
Family Insurance Services logo

Family Insurance Services

10327 Dawsons Creek Blvd Ste C-1, Fort Wayne, IN 46825
Visit Website
  • Homeowners

Family Insurance Services caters to clients in Fort Wayne and the nearby areas. It helps clients protect their homes and families by applying for homeowners' insurance products. These products cover clients' repair and temporary expenses if a fire or explosion damages their homes or possessions. It also benefits a guest or a stranger who obtained injuries while inside the clients' premises. Family Insurance Services is an independent company with over 25 years of experience in the industry.

Visit Website
G A MacDonald Associates logo

G A MacDonald Associates

2200 Lake Avenue, Fort Wayne, IN 46805
Visit Website
  • Condos
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Homeowners
  • Multiple Policy Types
  • Personal Property Insurance
  • Fire
  • Earthquake

G A MacDonald Associates is an insurance agency in Fort Wayne. Its independent insurance agents have been providing insurance solutions for homeowners in the metro for more than 30 years. They are dedicated to shopping for policies that can help each client mitigate the risks unique to their homes and belongings. The firm can also extend its assistance to policyholders during the claims process, coordinating with third-party vendors who can handle water and fire damage restoration.

Visit Website
GMI Insurance logo

GMI Insurance

1737 Morningstar Blvd., Decatur, IN 46733
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance

GMI Insurance offers home insurance policies to homeowners in Fort Wayne. Its products also include property liability and flood damage coverages that protect residential premises from the financial impact of accidents and natural disasters. When helping clients choose, it considers the structure and value of the property's contents. The company also has farm and boat insurance policies in its catalog. Teresa Turzillo, a company agent, has over 28 years of experience handling property, casualty, life, accident, and health insurance plans.

Visit Website
Godschalk and Associates logo

Godschalk and Associates

405 Lower Huntington Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46819
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types
  • Homeowners

Godschalk and Associates is an independent insurance agency that provides home insurance in Fort Wayne, Indiana and throughout northeast Indiana. The company offers home insurance options that protect residential households against fire, burglary, weather damage, and other unforeseen events. Since 1982, the company has offered home insurance and other insurance products to commercial and personal clients from a variety of carriers. Godschalk and Associates also sells auto, property, life, and business insurance.

Visit Website
Graber Insurance Incorporated logo

Graber Insurance Incorporated

955 US 27 N, Berne, IN 46711
Visit Website
  • Multiple Carriers
  • Multiple Policy Types

Graber Insurance Incorporated provides services to clients in the Fort Wayne community. It helps individuals apply for homeowners insurance policies to protect their finances if their homes face damages due to disasters and accidents. It also guides renters who need insurance plans for their personal belongings inside their apartments. Its team is also available for pet, life, health, farm, and business insurance products. Graber Insurance Incorporated represents carriers such as Anthem BlueCross BlueShield, CNA Surety, First Comp, Progressive, and American Collectors.

Visit Website
Gregory Associates, Inc. logo

Gregory Associates, Inc.

4011 W Jefferson Blvd Ste 225, Fort Wayne, IN 46804
Visit Website
  • Condos

Gregory Associates, Inc., has been offering insurance policies to clients in Fort Wayne since 1933. Homeowners can get financial protection in case of fire or natural disasters to their property. The policy also covers theft, vandalism, and injuries that occur inside the property. In addition, the firm offers insurance for vehicles like cars, motorcycles, boats, and yachts. Businesses can also cover for workers' compensation claims and professional liability suits. Founder Samuel Gregory Sr. had worked as an agent for another insurance firm prior to establishing his own.

Visit Website
Heartland Insurance Partners logo

Heartland Insurance Partners

10305 Dawson's Creek Blvd Ste F, Fort Wayne, IN 46825
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance

Heartland Insurance Partners is an independent, multi-line agency that serves Fort Wayne. Included in its products is homeowners' insurance, which helps pay for property damage and reimburses losses in case of theft. Its team also furnishes home protection plans that include living expenses and liability coverage. The risk advisors have access to policies from a broad range of providers, including Progressive, Foremost, and Safeco Insurance. Agency owner Brett Hess has been providing risk management solutions since 2002.

Visit Website
Insurance Management Group logo

Insurance Management Group

12730 Coldwater Road Suite 103, Fort Wayne, IN 46845
Visit Website
  • Multiple Carriers
  • Multiple Policy Types

Insurance Management Group was founded in 1954 to serve the Fort Wayne community. The agency helps individuals feel confident about their future by offering personal insurance policies like homeowners', renters', car, and life. The homeowners' insurance plan protects the clients' dwelling, belongings, and liability. Its agents address clients' questions, review their coverage, and guide them throughout the process. In addition, they provide business and employer insurance products. In 2021, Big I Indiana named Insurance Management Group the Agency of the Year.

Visit Website
Kristin Pease logo

Kristin Pease

6424 Lima Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46818
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Condos

Kristin Pease is a State Farm insurance agent serving clients in Fort Wayne and the surrounding communities. With over 15 years of experience in the field, she handles insurance products and services for homes, automobiles, and pets. She also provides life and health insurance and offers coverage options for businesses. Also available are insurance policies for recreational vehicles and boats. In addition, Kristin and her team assist clients with banking and annuities.

Visit Website
Larry Ice II logo

Larry Ice II

6221 Maplecrest Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46835
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Homeowners

For over 16 years, Larry Ice II has been providing insurance solutions to clients in Fort Wayne. Ice is a State Farm insurance agent that offers homeowners' insurance options. He educates clients on further protection through liability insurance coverage. Ice deals with other insurance products, like pet, life, health, and auto insurance. He also aids clients with business insurance solutions, including commercial auto and employment practices liability insurance. Clients can opt for banking and mutual fund services.

Visit Website
Marcus Elam logo

Marcus Elam

1611 S Calhoun Street, Fort Wayne, IN 46802
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Homeowners

Marcus Elam is an insurance agent who offers various policies for homeowners in Fort Wayne and the surrounding areas. Through its wide range of coverage options, these policies protect homeowners from paying a large amount of money for damages to their homes. Elam is the owner of a State Farm agency that has been operating for more than 40 years. Aside from homeowners' insurance, Elam also provides insurance products focused on renters, businesses, health, and life.

Visit Website
Mettler Insurance Agency logo

Mettler Insurance Agency

616 N Jefferson Street, Huntington, IN 46750
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types

Mettler Insurance Agency serves clients in Fort Wayne and nearby areas. Its agents help individuals acquire homeowners' insurance and set financial limits in their coverage. The company's offerings include protection plans for individual health and different types of vehicles. Its team also crafts insurance for bonds, workers' compensation, general liability, commercial properties, and business vehicles. Mettler Insurance Agency has been in operation since 1950. Some of the carriers it partners with are Liberty Mutual and Foremost.

Visit Website
Mid–State Farmers Mutual Insurance Company logo

Mid–State Farmers Mutual Insurance Company

1008 Lincoln Hwy E., New Haven, IN 46774
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types

For more than 125 years, Mid-State Farmers Mutual Insurance Company has been catering to home and farm owners in Fort Wayne and the surrounding areas. Its group of local agents specializes in homeowners' and farm-related insurance products. They assist clients in finding the right coverage for their properties, including homes and personal belongings inside, farmhouses, barns, livestock, wood burners, and other farm equipment. As a mutual company, Mid-State Farmers is owned and run by its policyholders.

Visit Website
Mitson Insurance Agency logo

Mitson Insurance Agency

6500 East State Boulevard, Fort Wayne, IN 46815
Visit Website
  • Multiple Carriers
  • Multiple Policy Types

For over 55 years, Mitson Insurance Agency has been serving individuals, families, and businesses in Fort Wayne and neighboring areas. Its group of agents advises clients on coverage choices for many types of insurance, including life, health, auto, homeowners, and business. The agency has access to several carriers, such as CNA Surety, Safeco Insurance, The Hartford, and Foremost Insurance Group. Its commercial clients include restaurants, manufacturers, contractors, churches, schools, and retail stores.

Visit Website
Oakwood Mutual logo

Oakwood Mutual

1733 Morningstar Boulevard, Decatur, IN 46733
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types

Oakwood Mutual provides risk management solutions for individuals and families in Fort Wayne. It offers homeowners' insurance policies that help pay for repairs, loss of valuables, personal liabilities, and living expenses in the event of a disaster, theft, or vandalism. The agency also provides insurance products for farms, renters, and automobiles. Incorporated in 2019 following the merger between Mutual Insurance Association of Southern Indiana and German Mutual Insurance Company of Indiana, the agency has more than 250 years of combined industry experience.

Visit Website
Pletcher Insurance, Inc. logo

Pletcher Insurance, Inc.

132 South Main Street, North Webster, IN 46555
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types

Pletcher Insurance, Inc., has been catering to residential clients and business owners in and around the Fort Wayne area for more than four decades. The agency provides homeowners' insurance that covers properties, such as houses, mobile homes, condominiums, and rental properties. It also offers other insurance products, including auto, recreational vehicle, business, and life insurance. The agency writes Medicare supplements, annuities, and long-term care. Founder Dave Pletcher brings over five decades of experience in the insurance industry.

Visit Website
Portland Insurance logo

Portland Insurance

115 E Main St, Portland, IN 47371
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Condos
  • Earthquake
  • Flood

Since 1935, Portland Insurance has been offering a variety of policies to clients in the Fort Wayne area. Its homeowners' insurance provides compensation for damage caused by natural disasters or fires. It also covers injuries that occur inside the residence, along with stolen personal items and vandalism. In addition, clients can get insurance for their vehicles, such as autos, motorcycles, boats, and RVs. The company also covers companies for workers' compensation claims and professional liability suits.

Visit Website
Reick Insurance Agency logo

Reick Insurance Agency

110 E Rush St, Kendallville, IN 46755
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types

Reick Insurance Agency is a non-affiliated brokerage that serves families and businesses in Fort Wayne. It offers various insurance products, such as homeowners', auto, health, life, pet, and commercial. Homeowners' insurance can provide financial protection for untoward incidents borne by clients' houses, other structures in the property, personal belongings, and costs incurred because of a covered loss. Reick Insurance Agency was founded in 1944. Owner and president Lou Zabona has been in the insurance industry for more than two decades.

Visit Website
Roehrs-McMillen, Inc. logo

Roehrs-McMillen, Inc.

414 Clinton St, Defiance, OH 43512
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance

Roehrs-McMillen, Inc., is a locally owned and operated insurance firm established in 1930. It helps individuals and families in Fort Wayne secure their financial future through personal insurance plans, such as home, auto, life, and renters'. In addition, the agency offers business and farm insurance products. Roehrs-McMillen deals with the carriers like Celina Insurance Group and Goodville Mutual Casualty Company. One client complimented the company for being responsive to his concerns and helpful with his auto and homeowners' insurance plans.

Visit Website
Starks Family Insurance logo

Starks Family Insurance

3526 Stellhorn Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46815
Visit Website
  • Multiple Policy Types

Starks Family Insurance is an independent agency that caters to clients in Fort Wayne. Among the products it offers is homeowners' policy, which insures dwellings against natural disasters, theft, or vandalism. It also covers liabilities the policyholders may incur due to injuries or damage to guests while on their premises. The firm's agents search through various carriers to find a package that fits clients' needs. Policyholders can modify their policies directly from the company's website 24/7.

Visit Website
The David Spear Agency logo

The David Spear Agency

1002 Dehner Dr., Ossian, IN 46777
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Condos

The David Spear Agency caters to the residents of Fort Wayne and the surrounding areas. Its insurance plans for houses, condominiums, and apartments cover financial losses due to theft, vandalism, and fire. The agency also offers an umbrella insurance policy, which comprises coverage for medical, living, property, and protection expenses. It has risk management products for various vehicles, such as motorcycles, cars, and boats. The company works with different partners, including Allstate, Safeco, and Progressive.

Visit Website
The DeHayes Group logo

The DeHayes Group

11118 Coldwater Road, Fort Wayne, IN 46845
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance

The DeHayes Group is a Fort Wayne-based independent agency working with over 40 insurance carriers to provide various protection policies like homeowners' insurance. Its agents compare available products and guide clients in selecting their options, from among fire, property damage, medical expenses, and liability coverage policies. They also assist in putting together features in a package, to better accommodate the distinct requirements of policyholders. Other products offered by the firm include auto, individual life, and umbrella indemnity plans. The DeHayes Group received the Fort Wayne Newspapers Readers' Choice award for 2021.

Visit Website
True Value Insurance Agency, LLC logo

True Value Insurance Agency, LLC

6368 E US Highway 224, Craigville, IN 46731
Visit Website
  • Renter's Insurance

True Value Insurance Agency, LLC, offers a variety of products from different carriers to Fort Wayne clients. It provides property insurance for renters, landlords, and owners of homes, condominiums, and mobile homes. It also offers life, business, health, liability, and auto policies. Agency owner Kent Brown conducts routine audits, trains employees, evaluates policies, and assists with claims. The company is mostly cyber-based and employs a computerized and technological approach in its effort to go green.