Expertise.com
2024

Last updated:

Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Fishers

Our Recommended Top 13

We did the research for you!

  • Licensing
  • User Reviews
  • Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Fishers Local Car Insurance Agencies on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.

56

Reviewed

38

Curated

13

Top Picks

Learn about our selection process.

Providers

featured provider = Featured Provider

Website
8767 South Street, Fishers, IN 46038
  • Boats
  • Motorcyle & ATV

Why choose this provider?

Osborn Insurance Agency is a small and independent agency in Fishers that provides car insurance services. It has been serving the community and the nearby areas since 2005. Its team of agents has over 40 years of combined experience and works with various insurance carriers to provide customized insurance products that are suited to the clients' needs. The company believes in the principle of providing immediate assistance to the community when a disaster strikes.

License Verified:

License: 38215

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.9
Google
4.9 / 5 (32)
Facebook
4.3 / 5 (3)
Yelp
5.0 / 5 (2)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
11447 Overlook Drive, Fishers, IN 46037
  • Multiple Carriers

Why choose this provider?

Ray Insurance Group is a full-service, independent insurance firm based in Fishers. Its team of experienced agents specializes in helping clients secure various types of personal insurance plans, including auto insurance. They present vehicle owners with options from multiple carriers, to find which one will suit the clients’ individual needs and risks. Coverage types protect the motorist from the costs of bodily or property injury liability, medical payments, collision, accidents caused by uninsured and underinsured motorists, and non-collision auto damage.

License Verified:

License: 7894632

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.9

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
7050 East 116th Street, Fishers, IN 46038
  • Multiple Carriers

Why choose this provider?

Priority Risk Management is a full-service independent insurance agency in Fishers. It provides a wide range of car insurance coverage options to clients that protect the car, its owner, and other people who may be injured due to negligence. The firm can provide policies that cover collisions, property damage, comprehensive coverage, bodily injury, and uninsured or underinsured liability. The agency can compare the coverages offered by different insurance providers to determine the ideal one depending on clients' needs.

License Verified:

License: 35780

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
5.0
Google
5.0 / 5 (92)
Facebook
4.9 / 5 (27)
Yelp
5.0 / 5 (3)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
4800 West Smith Valley Road, Greenwood, IN 46142
  • Multiple Carriers

Why choose this provider?

Eric Kwiatkowski is a State Farm insurance agent based in Greenwood who serves the Fishers community. He and his team specialize in auto, life, renters', homeowners', general liability, and business insurance. They accept consultations and provide potential clientele with quotes for auto insurance. They aim to provide assistance to their clients, especially during unfortunate events. His agency hopes to build a lasting personal relationship with its clients. Kwiatkowski extends his services to Bargersville, Indianapolis, Whiteland, and other nearby areas.

License Verified:

License: 3541320

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
5.0
Facebook
5.0 / 5 (3)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
53 West Main Street, New Palestine, IN 46163
  • Multiple Carriers
  • Bundling Option

Why choose this provider?

Smith Insurance is a car insurance agency in New Palestine that also serves clients in the Fishers area. Since 1980, the company's insurance agents have been offering various coverage options, including collision coverage, diminishing deductible, liability coverage, personal injury protection (PIP), rental reimbursement, and towing. They also provide comprehensive coverage as well as quotes that include medical payments and roadside assistance. The team at Smith Insurance represents several carriers, such as Auto-Owner's Insurance, Allied Insurance, Progressive, and Transamerica.

License Verified:

License: 1035318

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
5.0
Facebook
5.0 / 5 (2)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
5645 North Post Road, Indianapolis, IN 46216
  • Bundling Option

Why choose this provider?

Insurance by George, Inc. is an independent insurance agency that offers auto insurance in the Fishers and other neighboring areas in Indiana for more than 10 years. It strives to ensure that both the client's short-term and long-term plans are put into perspective when providing a deal that fits. The agency has established a solid partnership with several insurance carriers including Erie Insurance, Foremost, Progressive, Nationwide, and Midland National Life Insurance. They also offer services for business, life, and health insurance.

License Verified:

License: 560818

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.7
Google
4.9 / 5 (12)
Facebook
5.0 / 5 (4)
Yelp
3.0 / 5 (2)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
601 Conner Street, Noblesville, IN 46060
  • Multiple Carriers
  • Motorcyle & ATV

Why choose this provider?

Dear Nina, Pls remove some of the details about services and replace them with peculiar/unique info from the following page: https://www.shepherdins.com/ It's ok even if the snippet doesn't mostly discuss services. Our new guideline is to make sure that a snippet is not generic and has a balance between services and unique attributes of the company. The reason is that we want our snippets to have more value than just being a generic snippet. If you have further questions, please send me a slack message. - Sophia Shepherd Insurance was founded in 1977 by David Shepherd. It is an independent agency providing its commercial, personal, and financial insurance services to clients in Fishers and the nearby areas. The agency helps its clients with auto insurance to protect them from financial losses due to an accident. Shepherd Insurance also offers insurance services for collector cars, motorcycles, boat insurance, and recreational vehicles. Additionally, the agency also provides business solutions.

License Verified:

License: 3142707

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.2
Facebook
4.3 / 5 (44)
Google
4.2 / 5 (10)
Yelp
3.0 / 5 (6)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
7212 Shadeland Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46250
  • Multiple Carriers

Why choose this provider?

Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group is an independent agency that assists vehicle owners in Fishers regarding auto insurance products and services. It represents multiple carriers such as Progressive, Safeco, Nationwide, Grange Insurance, and Travelers in providing insurance plans. The president, Scott Wenclewicz, has been in the industry since April of 2006. The company's team of insurance specialists accommodates clients in customizing and choosing the coverages that are suited to their needs, which may include collision and comprehensive coverages.

License Verified:

License: 3297141

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
5.0
Google
5.0 / 5 (110)
Facebook
5.0 / 5 (34)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
4202 East New York Street, Indianapolis, IN 46201
  • RV & Motorhome
  • Motorcyle & ATV

Why choose this provider?

Since 2014, Indy Select Insurance has been providing auto insurance policies to clients in Fishers. As an independent agency, it works with multiple carriers, helping clients have adequate coverage in the event of a loss. Additionally, it also has insurance plans for drivers with SR22s and SR50s, as well as commercial autos, motorcycles, and RVs. Indy Select Insurance owner Katrina Harmon has been in the insurance industry since 2003 and also offers home and renters' insurance.

License Verified:

License: 965815

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.7
Google
4.5 / 5 (39)
Facebook
5.0 / 5 (16)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
11393 Lantern Road, Fishers, IN 46038
  • Motorcyle & ATV

Why choose this provider?

Rhodes Insurance Group is an agency in Fishers that offers car insurance products to residents in the metro and in nearby areas. The company writes policies to protect personal and commercial vehicles and cover unexpected expenses. It is currently headed by Scott Rhodes, an insurance agent with more than 30 years of industry experience. Rhodes Insurance Group actively participates in community advocacies and has provided help to causes such as the Youth Mentoring Initiative and Meals on Wheels.

License Verified:

License: 1060700

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.9
Google
4.9 / 5 (54)
Yelp
5.0 / 5 (1)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
8756 East 116th Street, Fishers, IN 46038
  • Multiple Carriers

Why choose this provider?

Brightway Insurance is a Fishers-based independent insurance agency. It works with more than a hundred insurance carriers in providing for the insurance needs of its clients, including auto insurance. The auto insurance coverage of the agency includes physical damage liability and property damage liability, which are important to consider when the car owner gets involved in an accident. The agency's owner, Man Phung, has over 10 years of sales experience and is fluent in English and Vietnamese.

License Verified:

License: 3631658

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.5
Google
4.6 / 5 (56)
Yelp
1.0 / 5 (1)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
4.8
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
13578 East 131st Street , Suite 270, Fishers, IN 46037
  • Multiple Carriers
  • Motorcyle & ATV
  • Boats
  • RV & Motorhome

Why choose this provider?

Curry Agency Inc. is an independent insurance agency based in Fishers providing customers personalized car insurance products. The agency's founder, Todd Curry, has over 12 years of experience working with a large publicly traded insurer in the country. He started Curry Agency with the goal of building successful relationships with clients through delivering outstanding service. Its insurance agents recommend paying higher deductibles for comprehensive and collision coverage as a cost-effective way to lower premiums. Other products are life, health, and home insurance.

License Verified:

License: 706629

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.8
Google
4.9 / 5 (31)
Facebook
4.5 / 5 (8)
Yelp
5.0 / 5 (3)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Website
802 Mulberry Street, Noblesville, IN 46060
  • Multiple Carriers
  • Motorcyle & ATV
  • Boats
  • RV & Motorhome

Why choose this provider?

Denstorff Insurance Agency is an insurance company that started in 2006. The company considers its customer's budgets, owned vehicles, and other insurance coverages in helping clients pick the appropriate auto insurance plans. These can include add-on coverages, like accident and legal payments. The auto insurance plans can also cover repairs and the replacement of the insured car. Denstorff Insurance Agency works with multiple carriers, such as AAA, Nationwide, and State Auto Insurance. The company also provides life and homeowners' coverage.

License Verified:

License: 771728

Indiana Department Of Insurance

Reputation:

We scour the internet for reviews from well-known resources. Each provider is evaluated based on the quality and quantity of their reviews, their presence on multiple review sites, and their average minimum rating.
4.9
Google
5.0 / 5 (22)
Facebook
4.6 / 5 (11)

Professionalism:

We hire mystery shoppers to call our providers anonymously and evaluate them. Providers who respond quickly, answer questions thoroughly, and communicate politely score higher.
5.0
Responsiveness
Friendliness
Helpfulness
Detail

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Introduction

    A way to stay protected while on the road, car insurance offers a financial safety net should accidents occur, regardless of who's at fault. The right car insurance agency can be very valuable, providing a way to purchase an ideal level of auto insurance coverage for personal circumstances. Agencies can help customers select the most beneficial coverage options while saving money on their insurance plan. With help from a qualified agency, it's possible to feel safe and secure behind the wheel.

  • What rating factors are taken into account when calculating auto insurance premiums in Fishers?

    Fishers auto insurance companies consider your age when calculating policy premiums. Drivers under the age of 25 and over the age of 65 frequently pay higher insurance premiums because studies show that these two age groups have the highest frequency of financial losses in car accidents. Other factors considered when determining insurance costs include a person's driving history, household income, car type, and credit score.

  • What is Fishers' required minimum level of coverage for auto insurance?

    Indiana mandates that drivers from Fishers carry at least the minimum levels of bodily injury liability and property damage liability coverage in order to legally operate a motor vehicle. Commonly referred to as the 25/50/25 coverage, it protects against bodily injury liability of $25,000 per person, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage.

  • What is the typical monthly cost of vehicle insurance in Fishers?

    Fishers residents spend an average of $148 per month, or $1,770 per year, on the state-mandated minimum liability insurance. However, it is critical to understand that vehicle insurance can vary significantly depending on a driver's specific circumstances. Shopping around for auto insurance quotes is the simplest way to get an accurate estimate of your insurance costs.

  • Is it possible to obtain a car insurance in Fishers even if you do not own a vehicle?

    Yes, it is possible to obtain car insurance in Fishers even if you do not own a vehicle. Non-owner car insurance is a policy designed for people who occasionally drive cars they do not own, such as borrowed or rented vehicles. It provides liability coverage and can be a practical solution for those who do not own a vehicle but require insurance when driving others' cars. This type of insurance costs an average of $291 per year in Fishers.

  • How long would a car accident in Fishers affect a person's auto insurance?

    Your auto insurance rates will not be affected by a collision indefinitely. In Fishers, your rates should recover in about three to five years on average. This will also be largely dependent on the type of accident you experienced as well as the different algorithms used by each insurance provider for their clients.

  • What is car insurance?

    Car insurance is a form of insurance that can cover damages to cars, drivers, passengers, and other property when an accident occurs. If another car crashes into a driver, or if a driver causes an accident, car insurance will pay most or all of the cost of repairs.