Best Health Insurance Agencies in Evansville

Founded in 2006, Craig Benefit Group is a privately owned insurance brokerage based in Evansville. The independent firm specializes in insurance solutions for individuals, businesses, and seniors. Craig Benefit Group's comprehensive insurance products include employee benefits, Medicare supplements for those who are planning for their retirement, travel insurance, life insurance, annuities, and safe money solutions. The firm is led by its president, Gary Craig, who is also an independent insurance broker.

Headquartered in Evansville, Insurance & Business Planning, Inc., is an insurance agency that has provided insurance services to residents and businesses in the Tri-State area near Evansville since 1978. It specializes in serving individual, family, and employer group health, Medicare, and life plans. It carries insurance plans such as individual health insurance, Medicare supplements, Medicare Advantage plans, short-term health plans, and travel medical insurance. Additionally, it provides annuity plans like single life annuities, joint life annuities, qualified annuities, and non-qualified annuities.

Newbury Financial is a senior benefits agency based in Evansville. Its independent brokers partner with several insurance providers, including Anthem and Mutual of Omaha, and carry Medicare Supplement insurance plans. They educate clients about the features of the original Medicare program and its differences from the Medicare Advantage plans. Newbury Financial also offers long-term care and senior burial insurance. J Scott Burke, its owner, has been an insurance agent since 1996. He works with his wife, Jo, a certified financial planner.

Smiley Face Insurance, an independent insurance agency specializing in senior insurance solutions, serves the insurance needs of individuals and families in Evansville and all of Southern Indiana. It helps clients find insurance policies that match their needs. It carries insurance plans like Medicare advantage plans, Medicare supplement insurance plans, Medicare Part D prescription plans, and supplemental insurance. Additionally, it provides final expense plans, life insurance, and travel insurance. Thomas D. “T.D.” Scholl is the founder and owner of Smiley Face Insurance.

Stevens Insurance Advisors is an independent health advising firm based in Evansville. The firm assists clients in choosing Medicare and health insurance plans that are appropriate for their needs. It offers options for Medicare, including Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Part D. It lends advice to clients seeking health insurance plans like the Affordable Care Act and Affordable Care Act subsidies. Ken Stevens leads the firm. He has over 30 years of experience working in health insurance and financial institutions.