Best Consignment
Shops in

Why These Consignment Shops?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored consignment shops on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best consignment shops in Chicago, IL.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks6784109

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

Buy Popular Demand

Buy Popular Demand provides discerning customers in the Chicago area with high-quality consignment items. The family owned and operated business has been a premiere women’s consignment boutique for more than 20 years. The upscale shop specializes in carrying a wide selection of quality resale clothing, shoes, jewelry, and other accessories at a fraction of the original retail price. Customers can always expect to find an exciting array of items ranging from dresses to fur coats. Buy Popular Demand focuses on stocking a mix of trendy, modern, and fashionable classic designer styles from which customers can choose. The talented consignment intake specialists welcome items less than three years old and in excellent condition. Buy Popular Demand commits to providing customers with the highest quality resale items at prices that will not break the bank.

Chicago, IL(773) 868-0404


Cynthia’s Consignments

Cynthia’s Consignments has been a go-to spot for top-of-the-line luxury designer brand fashions at a fraction of the original retail price for over 20 years. The upscale Chicago-area resale boutique specializes in providing customers with the highest quality merchandise from some of the top designers in the world including Gucci, Hermes, Prada, Chanel, Versace, and Manolo Blahnik. Discerning customers can rely on Cynthia’s Consignments to seek out and display the most up-to-date luxury clothing, handbags, and shoes available. Talented consignment intake specialists carefully select each item to ensure authenticity and quality. Cynthia’s Consignments commits to providing an exciting shopping experience where customers can peruse and an array of fashionable clothing and discover the occasional rare find. The shop also provides convenient closet cleaning services and complimentary clothing pickups.

Chicago, IL(773) 248-7714


Elliott Consignment

Elliott Consignment has been a fixture in the Chicago area for more than 20 years. The upscale family owned and operated consignment shop carries men’s and women’s luxury brand designer fashions at a fraction of the original retail price. Friendly designer consignment intake specialists welcome gently worn items less than two years old as well as brand new, never used items. Elliott Consignment offers an incredible selection of designer labels including Gucci, Armani, Prada, Valentino, Michael Kors, Dolce & Gabbana, and more. The upscale shop is recognized as one of the top designer resale shops in Chicago by The Reader, and as one of America’s top designer resale shops by The Desi Mag. Elliott Consignment commits to maintaining the most fashionable designer items and providing customers with a unique and fun shopping experience.

Chicago, IL(773) 404-6080


Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ

Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ has been helping people turn closet contents into cash for nearly a decade. The Chicago-area upscale consignment store provides a fun and unique shopping experience complete with stylish, trendy clothing for a fraction of the original price. The shop specializes in consigning new or gently used designer items. Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ offers and expansive collection of women’s luxury items by top-notch designers like YSL, Armani, Louis Vuitton, Chanel, Prada, and many others. Work and play apparel designers including Ralph Lauren, Coach, Eileen Fisher, and J. Crew are also available at the trendy shop. Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ supports local fashion designers and features new items for sale in the store. The friendly staff knows that accessories are the holy grail of resale and encourage consignors to bring in handbags, sunglasses, scarves, watches, and jewelry. The shop pays consignors monthly, offers local pick-up service, closet cleanouts, and aggressively markets items on eBay, Facebook, and Instagram.

Chicago, IL(773) 447-8527


My Sister’s Closet

My Sister’s Closet provides discerning shoppers with the ultimate resale boutique experience. The upscale Chicago-area consignment shop has been a mainstay for fashionistas on a budget for more than 30 years. The unique resale boutique maintains 6,000 square feet of space that feature some of the trendiest and most fashionable items available. My Sister’s Closet specializes in carrying women’s and children’s clothing, accessories, books, antiques, collectibles, and gift items. Customers can expect to find an array of quality brands from which to choose including Gap and Chanel. My Sister’s Closet has something for everyone from women’s sizes zero to plus, maternity apparel, workout clothing, perfumes, and new cosmetics. The talented fashion intake specialists at the shop carefully hand select each item featured in the store to ensure the highest level of quality.

Chicago, IL(773) 774-5050


Sophie’s Closet Consignment Boutique

Sophie’s Closet Consignment Boutique is a go-to destination for an array of designer clothing labels at a fraction of the original retail price. The Chicago-area shop specializes in providing high-quality designer apparel, fashion accessories, and home décor items that are both stylish and affordable. Customers can always expect to find the most in-style casual wear, formalwear, business attire in a variety of sizes from petite to extra-large. Sophie’s Closet Consignment Boutique has something for everyone including name brand designer clothing, shoes, fashion accessories, handbags, scarves, jewelry, furniture, and home décor at all price points. Ann Taylor, Banana Republic, Coach, DKNY, Liz Claiborne, and Gucci are some of the top designers available in the store. Sophie’s Closet Consignment Boutique welcomes customers to enjoy an upscale boutique shopping experience that will not break the bank. The shop also supports local crafters and artisans by featuring beautiful new handmade products for sale.

Chicago, IL(773) 313-3614


The Silver Umbrella

The Silver Umbrella offers Chicago-area fashionistas a great way to de-clutter closets and earn extra cash. The upscale family-owned shop specializes in offering customers trendy clothing, jewelry, shoes, accessories, housewares, and art at a fraction of the original retail price. The Silver Umbrella features designer and better quality new and gently used items for fashionable and environmentally conscious men and women. All consignment items are carefully selected and strategically merchandised to provide the highest possible visibility for client merchandise to sell. The talented clothing marketing specialists feature items on the online eBay store and simultaneously display them in the retail shop. The Silver Umbrella wants to help consignors earn back a portion of the original investment and receive the maximum return for items no longer needed. The store welcomes designer and contemporary brands, vintage, clothing, footwear, accessories, jewelry, and handbags, home goods, and art.

Chicago, IL(773) 675-6114



Trends is a go-to place for a fun and unique resale shopping experience. The Chicago-area consignment boutique offers an array of trendy and fashionable merchandise in virtually every size and style. The friendly and knowledgeable staff welcomes consignors with gently worn women’s designer fashion. Trends has something for everyone at a price point that will keep customers on-budget.

Oak Park, IL(708) 434-0801


York Furrier

York Furrier has been a go-to resource for the discerning fur garment collector for more than 80 years. The upscale Chicago-area store is a purveyor of exceptional quality fur garments and fine outerwear for women and men. York Furrier offers an expansive selection of garments of the highest quality materials available as well as accessories, novelties, and footwear. Customers can enjoy an unforgettable shopping experience while browsing the premiere inventory of sheared mink, beaver, feathered fox, trimmed cashmere, and much more. York Furrier has something for everyone and features a full range of sizes and lengths. The specialty store also offers a fur coat consignment service that will help customers sell quality gently used fur garments. The friendly and knowledgeable staff works one-on-one with clients to thoroughly inspect consignment garments. York Furrier experts ensure garments are of the highest quality and display the least amount of wear to determine the recommended resale value at the store. New York Furrier can also help customers with restyling of older garments to ensure many more years of use.

Elmhurst, IL(630) 832-2200


Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: