Laurels
Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in St. Petersburg
2021

34 Best St. Petersburg Homeowners Insurance Agencies

Our Top Picks
  • Our selection process
  • View our top picks

We scored 172 Homeowners Insurance Agencies in St. Petersburg, FL and Picked the Top 34

1st Auto and Home Insurance is an insurance company that was established in 1996 to serve clients in St. Petersburg and surrounding areas. Staffed with licensed and experienced agents and brokers, it provides home insurance solutions that protect residential property owners from financial risks resulting from weather-related property damage. Its insurance sales team also provides quality automobile insurance services that can help clients foot auto repair costs and medical expenses following car collisions.

Website

Academy Insurance Agency is a personal and commercial line insurance agency that covers clients in St. Petersburg. It was established in 2005 by Rose Wainwright, a 45-year veteran of the insurance industry. She and her team of agents provide homeowners' insurance policies for tenants, owners, and real estate buyers. They can compare the quotes and annual rates of policies from over 55 different insurance carriers. They can also process all billings and claims to these carriers, such as Progressive and Homeowners Choice.

Instagram Website

With five locations in the state, Ample Insurance is an independent insurance agency working with the residents of St. Petersburg. The agency offers homeowners insurance to support policyholders if their homes are damaged due to fires, large storms, and vandalism. Its team also sells add-ons to the homeowners insurance to cover repair costs in the event of flooding. Additionally, the agency has business, traditional and vintage auto, and watercraft insurance.

Anthony B. LoSchiavo is a GreatFlorida Insurance agent that serves clients in the St. Petersburg metro and nearby areas. LoSchiavo offers homeowners' insurance products and guides clients through various coverage types, including medical expenses, liability, and dwelling coverage. He carries other personal insurance solutions, like boat, auto, and motorcycle insurance. LoSchiavo also provides commercial insurance services, and clients can opt for umbrella and business insurance options. He has over 13 years of insurance experience.

Website

Arrington Insurance of Florida Inc. is a locally-owned and operated, independent insurance brokerage that's been providing insurance policies to residents of Saint Petersburg, Florida for more than 30 years. The company works with providers such as Nationwide and Florida Peninsula Insurance Company to provide homeowners insurance, as well as renters, landlord, condo, mobile home, and schedule property insurance policies. In addition to home insurance, Arrington Insurance of Florida Inc. offers auto, flood, and jewelry insurance.

Website

Bankers Insurance Group has been serving the St. Petersburg area for over 40 years. The company offers homeowners', renters', condos, landlords, and residential flood insurance. The policies aim to help protect clients' properties and keep their assets secure from damages caused by earthquakes and hurricanes. Its homeowners' insurance policy also covers clients against personal and animal liability, loss of use, and identity fraud. Bankers Insurance Group also serves the needs of commercial clients through builder's risk and business owners' insurance coverage.

Website

Bell Insurance Agency has been serving individuals in St. Petersburg and nearby areas since 1994. Its professionals have years of experience and are well-versed in the ins and outs of the industry. They help clients protect their assets by providing a wide range of products, including home, auto, and business insurance. Its home insurance includes condo, mobile home, under construction dwelling, and personal umbrella. The business extends its auto coverage to motorcycles, classic cars, and high-risk policies.

Website

Based in St. Petersburg, Bentley DeNight is an independent insurance agency serving clients throughout Florida's Sun Coast counties. It offers auto, property, commercial, and flood insurance for individuals and businesses. Its property insurance policies cover both homeowners and renters. It also protects various types of dwellings, such as condos, mobile homes, and coastal properties. With nearly two decades of operation, Bentley DeNight has established a broad roster of insurance carriers, including Citizens, Lloyd's, Progressive, and Safeco.

Website

Blankit Insurance Group is a personal and business insurance agency working with the residents of St. Petersburg and the surrounding communities. The agency sells homeowners insurance packages that reimburse the policyholder for repairs for damage done by wind, fire and smoke, and water. Its policies also protect valuable items inside and outside of clients' homes, including fine art and jewelry. Additionally, Blankit Insurance Group offers auto, umbrella, and renters insurance.

Bouchard Insurance, located in St. Petersburg, Florida, is an independent insurance agency that was founded in 1978. With offices in Tampa, Clearwater, Sarasota, Fort Myers, Kissimmee, and Maitland, Bouchard Insurance works with a range of underwriting companies to provide indemnity coverage options for homeowners including structural building coverage, personal liability, and home contents coverage in packages tailored to suit clients' needs. Bouchard Insurance also offers flood, auto, and business insurance services.

Website

Business & Family Insurors Inc. has been serving the St. Petersburg, Florida area since 1982. It's a company that thrives on offering personalized service and customizing policies to provide the best rates and most suitable coverage. The home insurance policies provided by Business & Family Insurors Inc. cover damage to the home and its contents when a financial loss occurs due to a covered reason. Customers can choose to include flood insurance or personal liability umbrella insurance in their policy, as well.

Website

Cathy Shadwick is an insurance agent at State Farm that serves individuals and businesses throughout the community of St. Petersburg. For more than 30 years, she has been assisting and helping customers in a wide variety of insurance products, including health, homeowners', auto, business, and life insurance. Her affiliation, State Farm, is an independent insurance agency composed of agents with a collective industry experience of over 100 years. It also supports various charities and local non-profit organizations, such as The Free Clinic and CASA.

Instagram Website

Comegys Insurance Agency is a financial services company that has been serving clients in St. Petersburg since 1939. The company provides homeowners' insurance and helps protect owners from slip-and-fall lawsuits through liability coverage. It also offers auto, motorcycle, and RV insurance. Commercial insurance products are also available from the company. Clients can choose from business liability, workers' compensation, and auto dealers' insurance. Mark Berset, the company's CEO, has over 45 years of experience in the insurance industry.

Website

Daniel Martinez is a full-service State Farm agent who serves St. Petersburg. He has been with the company since 2005, helping clients find insurance products that fit their needs. One of his offerings is homeowners' insurance, which provides coverage for home repairs required due to fires, floods, theft, and vandalism. Martinez and his team share more than 35 years of industry experience. They also carry other insurance products, such as life, auto, and health insurance.

Website

Freedom Insurance of Florida is an independent insurance agency serving Saint Petersburg, Tampa, and the surrounding areas. This veteran-owned company works with both individual and commercial clients. For local residents, the agency sources homeowners insurance policies from a wide range of local and national carriers, including Progressive, Personable Insurance, and Assurance America, to name just a few. In addition to home insurance, the agency can also assist clients with auto, life, health, and business insurance.

Website

Gator Auto Insurance Service is a Pinellas Park insurance agency that sells home insurance in the Tampa Bay area. With over 20 years of experience, the company offers home insurance for both old and new homes, manufactured homes, condos, and mobile homes. The company also provides coverage for businesses, automobiles, boats, recreational vehicles, motorcycles, and jet skis. Gator Auto Insurance Service offers comprehensive policies with reliable customer service and knowledgeable staff.

Website

Great South Insurance Agency serves clients in St. Petersburg and the surrounding areas. It offers different insurance policies that cover clients' needs, such as homeowners', condominium, auto, renters', and life insurance. The company works with various insurance carriers, including Progressive, FHB Insurance, Gerber Life Insurance Company, UPC Insurance, and Humana. Great South Insurance Agency also offers cyber liability protection for small businesses to cover damages once a data breach occurs.

Website

Gulf Coast is an independent insurance agency that caters to clients in St. Petersburg and the surrounding areas. It helps clients protect their residential properties, such as condominiums, apartments, and houses, by providing homeowners' insurance products. It covers the repair expenses of clients if their properties become damaged due to smoke, vandalism, falling objects, hails, and fires. The company was founded by Darren Green and Justin Kelly, who have been in the industry for over 10 years.

Website

Herndon Carr & Co. is an independent insurance agency that has been serving the St. Petersburg community for over 45 years. The agency represents a variety of insurance providers to help clients find ideal coverage for their luxury homes, condos, farms, and rental properties. It also sells insurance policies to protect high-value assets in clients' homes, such as jewelry and art. Additionally, the company offers auto, life and health, and business insurance.

Website

HH Insurance offers personal and business insurance coverage to clients in St. Petersburg. The company's professionals have over 200 years of combined experience, providing policies tailored to their needs. It offers a wide selection of products, including homeowners', life, and motorcycle insurance, in addition to valuable items and umbrella coverage. The company's homeowners' policy covers residential properties, waterfront condos, downtown apartments, and mobile homes. HH Insurance also has options for general liability, workers' compensation, and business owners' policy for its commercial clients.

Website

Italiano Insurance Services Inc. is an independently owned and operated insurance agency that has been serving the St. Petersburg community for over 60 years. The company offers homeowners insurance plans that protect the home in the event of hurricanes, sinkholes, and fires. Its packages also cover the contents of the home that may be damaged or stolen. Additionally, Italiano Insurance Services Inc. sells insurance policies to cover clients' businesses and automobiles.

Instagram Website

James Insurance Solutions is a multi-line agency that serves individuals and businesses in St. Petersburg and the neighboring communities. It provides several types of personal insurance options, including homeowners' insurance. It also offers wind, flood, motorcycle, inland marine, automobile, umbrella, and renters' insurance plans. The agency customizes business owners' and property, general liability, workers' compensation, and event insurance. Medicare Part A, B, C, and D plans are available. It has partnered with several insurance carriers, such as Foremost, Homeowners Choice, and Progressive.

Llewellyn Insurance Services caters to clients in St. Petersburg and the surrounding areas. It specializes in helping individuals protect their residential properties by providing homeowners' insurance products. It also carries various property insurance policies, including flood, condo, vacant dwelling, wind and hail, renters, and umbrella insurance. Other products include business, vehicle, and life insurance. Llewellyn Insurance Services is an independent insurance company that has been in the industry since 1990.

Website

Manatee Insurance Services Inc. is an independent insurance agency based in Bradenton, Florida, with over 35 years of experience providing home insurance throughout the Manatee County area. The agency offers coverage through several carriers and works to find the best possible policy to protect homes and valuables. Manatee Insurance Services helps reduce costs of covering homes with monitored alarm systems, deadbolts, smoke detectors, and sprinkler systems. Policies are also available for renters and landlords.

Website

Mark Wilson is an insurance agent with State Farm Insurance serving the residents of St. Petersburg and the surrounding areas. The agent has over 30 years of experience in the field, and he sells insurance packages for homeowners that protects the client's home in the event of natural disasters and vandalism. The policies also reimburse clients for stolen and damaged belongings in the home. Additionally, Wilson offers auto and business insurance.

Website

Moore Resources is a multi-line insurance agency based in St. Petersburg. It offers both personal and commercial policies, ranging from homeowners' insurance to general liability insurance. The agency's staff assesses the clients' financial needs and designs coverage plans, utilizing various carriers that meet their requirements. Moore Resources and its staff have helped different local businesses acquire insurance, including Tom White Painting and Restoration, Clean Streak Pressure Washing, and Bridgewater Commercial Real Estate.

Website

Mutual Insurance is an independent agency that caters to clients in St. Petersburg and the neighboring areas. It offers clients choices of homeowners' insurance packages that protect against unexpected events, such as windstorms, thefts, and fire. Its auto insurance policies include coverages for motorcycles, RVs, and trailers. The company also offers whole life, universal life, limited pay, and variable life insurance plans. It advises clients on commercial insurance options, including professional liability, business property and automobile, business interruption, and builders' risk insurance.

Website

Founded in 1962, Northeast Underwriters is an independent insurance agency located in Saint Petersburg, Florida. Home coverage specialists work with several A-rated carriers to offer clients the right policy to repair, replace, or rebuild their homes following a valid claim. Most plans cover the dwelling, personal items, such as furniture, clothing, and electronics, personal liability, medical payments, and loss of use from windstorms, hail, lightning, fire, theft, and vandalism. The company also provides auto and business insurance.

Website

Roca Insurance is an independent agency that's been providing insurance services to clients in St. Petersburg and its surrounding areas since 1995. Through its licensed agents, it offers several types of home insurance policies, including homeowners' and renters' plans. The company's home insurance products include fire, burglary, property liability, and condominium policies as well as new construction and older home insurance programs. Roca Insurance also offers automobile insurance along with coverage plans for businesses.

Website

Operating since 2005, Ross Insurance Group Inc. is a family-owned and operated, Saint Petersburg, Florida-based agency offering home insurance services to owners in need of coverage for property, personal belongings, and liability as well as clients who rent property and need to insure items inside leased dwellings. This agency is versed in special coverage areas including repair scams, flood damage, and hurricane deductibles. Aside from home insurance, Ross Insurance Group Inc. also structures coverage for automobiles and recreational lines.

Website

Solutions Insurance is a full-service, family-owned and operated independent insurance agency serving Florida with homeowners insurance shopped from dozens of carriers including Progressive, Edison, Frontline Insurance, and Florida Penninsula. The agency offers policies ranging from minimum required dwelling, personal property, and liability coverage to comprehensive insurance plans featuring flood and theft protection. The company also offers renters, condo, auto, motorhome, and RV insurance. Solutions Insurance is a member of the Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agents and USAAB.

Website

Strategic Insurance Services in Clearwater, Florida, has been providing homeowners insurance to the Saint Petersburg area since 2006. As an independent agency, it has established relationships with multiple highly rated insurance companies to offer customers comprehensive coverage and competitive pricing. Its policies safeguard owners and renters from personal property losses that occur in their houses and apartments. For further protection, Strategic Insurance Services also has private market flood insurance options with broader coverage than what the National Flood Insurance program offers.

Website

TBIG Insurance is an independent agency that has been serving St. Petersburg for more than 50 years. It offers home insurance that aims to help clients keep their real estate property and belongings protected in the event of an unexpected accident. This policy covers the repair and replacement expenses of damaged items. Policyholders can also acquire liability insurance if someone has suffered injuries in their properties. TBIG Insurance represents various carriers, including Heritage, Progressive, Nationwide, and Mercury.

Website

The Starboard Insurance Group Inc. is an independent agency that serves St. Petersburg. It offers a wide selection of products for individuals and families, such as homeowners', condo, auto, boat, and flood insurance. Its homeowners' insurance policy protects the client's property and belongings against damages and theft. The business also connects clients with commercial coverage, including general liability, builders risk, and business owners' policy. It represents an extensive network of carriers, such as Cigna, Travelers, Avatar, Allianz, and Berkshire Hathaway.

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: