Laurels
Best Property
Managers in Fort
Collins
2017

Why These Property Managers?

Our goal is to connect people with the best local experts. We scored property managers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analysed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best property managers in Fort Collins, CO.

ReviewedCuratedTop Picks41289

Our Selection Criteria:

  • 1. Reputation

    A history of delighted customers and outstanding service.

  • 2. Credibility

    Building customer confidence with licensing, accreditations, and awards.

  • 3. Experience

    Masters of their craft, based on years of practical experience and education.

  • 4. Availability

    Consistently approachable and responsive, so customers never feel ignored.

  • 5. Professionalism

    Providing service with honesty, reliability, and respect.

1st American Properties, LLC

1st American Properties, LLC is a full-service property management company that provides leasing and asset management services. The company is a member of the National Association of Realtors, the Colorado Association of Realtors, and the National Association of Residential Property Managers. 1st American Properties has almost a decade of experience in offering property management services for apartment buildings, single family homes, condos, townhomes, and duplexes in Loveland and the greater Fort Collins area. They take pride in maintaining low vacancy rates for owners' properties through aggressive marketing. 1st American Properties screens every tenant's credit, employment, and eviction history, and they review landlord references. The company provides frequent property inspections and 24-hour emergency services. Every time a tenant moves in or out of a property, 1st American Properties video records the property for a detailed condition assessment. Owners can benefit from electronic statements and reports, along with online document signing and storage. Renters can make rental payments in person, by check or online.

Loveland, CO(970) 631-0564

Website

All Country Larimer Property Management

All Country Larimer Property Management is a company in Fort Collins that specializes in property management. The company’s services include marketing, tenant screening, and lease negotiations. All Country also handles 24/7 maintenance requests and collects rent from tenants. All renter applications are reviewed by All Country to ensure accuracy, and candidates must pass a number background checks. All Country’s leases are examined and updated by an attorney that specializes in landlord-tenant law, and the company only hires licensed and insured independent contractors to do property maintenance. All Country offers online services that allow owners to receive payments online, and renters can pay bills electronically. Property owners mention that All Country Larimer Property Management “always answers their phones” that the staff is “very helpful.”

Fort Collins, CO(970) 825-1000

Website

Big Bear Properties

Big Bear Properties won the Best of Greely award in 2016 for property management. They offer rental properties for the UNC, CSU, Aims College and FRCC student populations. They also provide services for owners that include rent collection, term negotiation, and background checks. Big Bear Properties uses online services to advertise properties and to understand market trends. The company also has accounting and maintenance staff in-house for efficiency and cost-savings. Owners receive monthly statements and rent is automatically deposited into their bank accounts. Big Bear Properties manages all utilities and provides year-end reports for taxes.

Greeley, CO(970) 282-3490

Website

Dimensions Realty and Management, LLC

Dimensions Realty and Management, LLC is a complete brokerage service that provides property management and real estate services in Fort Collins. The company offers market studies, real estate appraisals, and general consulting services. Dimensions Realty and Management is a small business with 35 years of experience, and the owner personally oversees each client’s property. The company provides their clients with a monthly report showing income and expenses, and they handle all aspects of renting a property from advertising and showing to tenant screening and signing leases to evictions if necessary. A representative from Dimensions Realty and Management personally addresses any emergency that occurs on the property, and they will hire a professional when property repairs and maintenance require a skilled technician. Customers gladly recommend Dimensions Realty and Management because of their “incredible adaptability” with tenants and because of the company’s flexibility “to respond to urgent matters in a timely fashion.” Dimensions also sell residential, investment, and commercial property.

Fort Collins, CO(970) 490-1220

Website

Peak Property Management

Peak Property Management Co. is a small personalized property management company in Fort Collins. The company focuses on maintaining residential properties by giving each client personalized attention. Peak Property Management is a licensed company that complies with all state and federal laws. The company does not buy or sell real estate, but they carefully select suppliers and contractors that are on call to provide property maintenance and repair services 24/7. Peak Property Management offers services for property owners like property evaluation and inspections, advertising, showing, tenant screening, and leasing. They also handle security deposits and rent collection. Every month they provide the owner with online income and expense statements. Peak Property also offers end of the year financial reports, and renters can submit maintenance requests, make rent payments, and communicate with the company online.

Fort Collins, CO(970) 377-2717

Website

Picket Fence Properties

Picket Fence Properties is a property management company that offers services to investors and renters in the Fort Collins area. They provide reliable and professional assistance with the daily tasks of property ownership. Picket Fence Properties has more than 20 years of experience with helping Windsor residents find new homes. The staff's understanding of federal and state laws, including knowledge of Fair Housing and landlord-tenant law, provide quality results for investors. Picket Fence Properties also provide services for renters and property owners. Tenants can pay rent and submit maintenance requests online, while owners can consult statements online using a state-of-the-art portal system. Picket Fence Properties helps owners advertise and screen tenant applications. The company also works with owners by showing the property to potential tenants and by handling routine as well as emergency maintenance. Property owners praise Picket Fence Properties by saying that the “professionalism, follow up, and insistence with tenants” is an “invaluable asset” that give them “true peace of mind.”

Windsor, CO(970) 686-6544

Website

Serendipity Property Management

Serendipity Property Management and Real Estate offers services for residential rental properties in Fort Collins. The company buys, sells, and manages single-family, duplex, or four-plex properties. Serendipity helps homeowners with marketing, maintenance, and renovation, and they screen tenants, collect rent, deal with tenant disputes, and ensure legal compliance. Serendipity strives to provide the best service by efficiently managing their clients' properties. The company uses modern software that helps advertise properties and compare rental rates so that owners can maximize revenue and fill vacancies faster. Serendipity also uses their technology to complete standard background and credit checks, as well as review past rent payment history of potential tenants. The company can electronically collect rent from renters and directly deposit the money into owners' bank accounts.

Fort Collins, CO(970) 222-9504

Website

Soukup Property Management

Soukup Property Management is a property management company that provides services both for homeowners and renters. The company’s mission is to provide personalized services that empower owners and relate to renters in the Fort Collins area. Soukup carefully manages and maintains each property, and they offer marketing services and carefully screen potential tenants. Soukup's staff provide an in-depth knowledge of the area that helps them advise clients on how to adjust prices and how to advertise the property successfully. The company directly deposits rent in the owner’s bank account, and owners can gain access to statements that show the performance of the property through an online portal. Renters can use this portal to pay rent electronically and to submit maintenance requests.

Fort Collins, CO(970) 402-8267

Website

Trilogy Property Management

Trilogy Property Management is a professional, residential property management company that helps property owners and tenants in Fort Collins. They do not buy or sell properties, but they carefully screen potential tenants with a standard background, credit, and rent history checks. Twice a year, a representative of Trilogy Property Management visits and inspects every property they manage, and the company has a zero-tolerance policy for tenants that do not comply with lease terms or respect their rented properties. Trilogy hires repair and maintenance contractors that are fully licensed, and tenants can pay rent, review their contracts, and submit maintenance requests online. Trilogy Property Management advertises vacant properties online, and owners can get rent directly deposited into their bank account.

Fort Collins, CO(970) 404-1767

Website

Wrong city? Here are some nearby places: