Last updated:

Best Private Investigators in Buffalo, NY

Our Recommended Top 8

We did the research for you!

  • Licensing
  • User Reviews
  • Mystery Shopping Calls

Our goal is to connect people with the best local professionals. We scored Buffalo Private Investigators on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best.



8Top Picks

Learn about our selection process.


featured provider = Featured Provider

Buffalo, NY 14221 Rating

Why choose this provider?

Amherst Investigations, Inc. is a private investigation firm operating in the Buffalo area and providing civil investigation services since 1987. Always following stringent professional guidelines, the licensed and highly trained investigators at Amherst provide over forty specialized services to law firms and their clients, including accident and crash investigation, expert witness interrogation, domestic surveillance, forensic accounting, criminal records searches, missing person investigations, and technical surveillance countermeasures. Amherst's investigators consistently meet client's private and professional needs by carefully gathering facts and reconstructing events, always striving to work as accurately, efficiently, and effectively as possible. Principals Scott A. Stambach and Joseph Galone each have significant experience in the security and investigative field, and Amherst Investigations is licensed, bonded, and insured with a proven track record.

Depew, NY 14043 Rating

Review Sources

4.0 (4)

Why choose this provider?

V.I.P. Investigative Services is a full-service, comprehensive investigative company located in Buffalo and serving the entire Western New York area. V.I.P. consists of former law enforcement, security, and legal professionals who are committed to providing the highest quality investigative services. V.I.P. maintains close ties with the Buffalo Police Department and related organizations, including the National Association of Legal Investigators. V.I.P.'s services include pre-employment checks, background investigations, white collar crime investigations, fraud and embezzlement investigations, insurance investigations, workers compensation investigations, domestic investigations, process service, executive protection details, missing persons cases, personal security and bodyguard services, and more. V.I.P. also maintains a 24-hour hotline service that client's employees can call to report fraud, theft, abuse, and other issues which may be relevant to workplace claim investigations.

East Amherst, NY 14051 Rating

Why choose this provider?

Flex Investigations, LTD. is a private investigation firm located in Buffalo and offering specialized services throughout Western New York. Flex has a staff comprised of former law enforcement and military personnel with a combined total of over 65 years' experience. The firm offers a variety of services, and associates include trained specialists in areas such as background investigations, witness location and statement gathering, process service, arson investigation, dignitary protection, and polygraph testing. Flex maintains working contacts with state and federal agencies, as well as local police departments. Flex's experienced staff can handle most client needs, including assigning specialized associates and organizing complex jobs requiring multiple investigators. Although it covers most common private investigation services, Flex does not manage divorce investigations.

Niagara Falls, NY 14304 Rating

Why choose this provider?

Intelligence & Investigative Solutions, LTD., is a New York State licensed, insured, and bonded private investigation firm, founded by an industry professional with over 12 years of experience. The company offers research, surveillance, field investigation, and litigation support services throughout the Western New York area, including background checks, insurance liability assessments and case management, corporate and public records searches, trial monitoring, crime scene and accident investigations, witness interviews, computer forensics, and more. Intelligence & Investigative Solutions offers reasonable rates, including flat assignment where appropriate. In addition to private investigation services, Intelligence & Investigative Solutions sells a number of security products, including cameras, tracking equipment, audio equipment, personal protection devices, counter-surveillance gear, and specialty products exclusively for law enforcement personnel.

Buffalo, NY 14221 Rating

Why choose this provider?

Philip D. Smith & Associates, Inc. is a licensed New York State investigation firm operating in the Buffalo area since in 1986. President Philip D. Smith formed the company following a career of nearly 25 years as an FBI agent. They offer comprehensive, cost-effective consulting and investigative services including background investigations, witness location, accident investigations, liabilities claims, surveillance, missing persons, courthouse record checks, and environmental investigations. The firm uses the most recent electronic resources to stay on the forefront of private investigation and data retrieval techniques, and maintains professional affiliations including the Society of Former Agents of the FBI and the National Council of Investigation and Security Services. Philip D. Smith & Associates has a successful record of providing critical surveillance information to clients engaged in civil lawsuits.

Buffalo, NY 14214 Rating

Why choose this provider?

Omniscient Investigations is a small private investigation firm operating in the Buffalo, NY area. Founder and owner Bruce C. Wagner is an experienced Licensed Private Investigator and a member of the Associated Licensed Detectives of New York State (ALDONYS), the National Association of Legal Investigators (NALI), the International Private Investigators Union (IPIU) and the Buffalo Claims Association. The company's team of investigators provide a range of services for professional clients, including background checks, claims investigations, process service, criminal and civil defense support, and commercial investigations. Omniscient uses state-of-the-art databases and public records searches for conducting skiptracing and legal services and has a notary on staff for generating professional affidavits. Omniscient Investigations impresses customers with its timely, thorough, and cost-effective performance of wide-ranging investigative services.

Buffalo, NY 14202 Rating

Why choose this provider?

Prime Investigations, Inc., is a detective agency serving Buffalo and surrounding areas. It offers surveillance, motor vehicle, dog bite, missing person, marine, and employee investigation services. It also conducts investigations on civil and family matters, fraud, medical malpractice, witness location, and elder abuse. President and founder of Prime Investigations Al Liberatore served as a police scuba diver with the BPD underwater recovery team for 25 years. He is also an adjunct criminal justice professor.

92 W Main St, Gowanda, NY 14070 Rating

Review Sources

5.0 (11)

Why choose this provider?

Privacon Investigations incorporates traditional detective techniques and advanced technology to provide personalized investigation services to clients in Buffalo. Founder Sarah Martinez brings more than 10 years of investigative experience from the fields of investigative reporting and law enforcement. She was a former deputy sheriff who had handled hundreds of civil and criminal investigations annually. Martinez and her team perform investigations for cases involving missing persons, online dating scams, insurance, and individual background investigation.

Compare our Top Private Investigators

NameExpertise RatingAddressPromotionsLearn more
Amherst Investigations, Inc.
Buffalo, NY 14221
V.I.P. Investigative Services
Depew, NY 14043
Flex Investigations, LTD.
East Amherst, NY 14051
Intelligence & Investigative Solutions, LTD.
Niagara Falls, NY 14304
Philip D. Smith & Associates, Inc.
Buffalo, NY 14221
Omniscient Investigations
Buffalo, NY 14214
Prime Investigations, Inc.
Buffalo, NY 14202
Privacon Investigations
92 W Main St, Gowanda, NY 14070


  • Introduction

    Some cases grow cold without ever getting solved by the police, and others tend to be too unorthodox for the police since they're mainly limited to criminal cases. This is where private investigators come in.

    Private investigators, also known as PIs, offer a wide range of services, including finding missing persons, tracking marital infidelity, investigating theft, running background checks, verifying insurance claims, and collecting debts on behalf of their clients.

    PIs work on any case requiring extensive research and investigation. Their duties range from gathering vital facts and connecting clues to providing conclusive information regarding the case.
  • What is a private investigator?

    Private investigators are experienced individuals hired to carry out detective work. They are fact-finding experts who dedicate time and effort to gather evidence and reveal information that would be difficult to gain through ordinary means. Private investigators can either operate alone or work for an agency.

  • Are private detectives real?

    Yes, private investigators are real. They provide their expertise to anyone who needs an in-depth investigation for an important matter. Whether tracking a long-lost loved one, running background checks, finding missing persons, or conducting general research, private detectives operate with discretion and rarely make the news.

  • What do private investigators do?

    PI work involves a lot of information gathering and fact analysis. Their field assignments involve carefully following persons of interest, conducting surveillance, interviewing people, and, sometimes, going undercover to get more information. They use GPS tracking devices, video recorders, computers, and other technology to collect information.

  • How do private investigators work?

    Private investigators’ ability to conduct examinations and close cases without their targets knowing their involvement makes them very effective. A PI firm may have different personnel, each specializing in a particular field. From computer experts to web-data analysts and field officers, these agents work together to solve cases or complete an objective.

  • What is a private investigator allowed to do?

    PIs are civilians, so they're required to operate within the confines of the law. Private investigators search multiple online databases, public records, and open source files to collect information. However, they cannot bug phones or hack into online accounts to acquire protected information. They can conduct surveillance on people in public places, but they can't trespass into their homes or property.